The appraisal of a string instrument requires that the instrument be physically present at the time of the appraisal. This is not a feat which can be accomplished over the internet.
Many factors are involved in the determination of the value and origin of a violin, viola, cello, bass or bow.
Labels appearing inside of instruments can be extremely misleading.Likewise, on many occasions certificates can be either misleading of downright false. Some labels have been inserted into an instrument to deceive while others are inserted to inform the observer of the model after which the particular instrument was fashioned. Certificates can be falsified or even counterfeited.
The process of appraisal also must take into account the overall condition of an instrument with regard to cracks, replacement wood or patches in the actual body of the instrument, parts which may have been added later such as a neck, a rib or a top or back, thus making the instrument a composite. The level of craftsmanship is also an important factor in determining origin and value.
During the examination of the instrument there must be a determination as to age and school of origin or as to whether the instrument is of commercial production or the or the sole work of a master maker or the work of several makers employed by a master maker. The latter is known as a "shop violin."
It should be noted that old instruments of fine quality have seen a tremendous rise in value over the last few years; however, not all old instruments have enjoyed a major upward appreciation. Older commercial instruments meant for student use will not have the same ratio of upward appreciation as a genuine Italian,French or other master made instrument from a well known maker.
Over the years we have had a large number of requests to provide appraisal information over the internet. These requests come from persons who in many cases have inherited an instrument with an illustrious label such as Stradivari, Guarneri, Amati, Maggini, etc. Most of these instruments are common commercial production which took place in either Germany or Bohemia from about 1840 to approximately the 1950's. Such instruments should be taken to local qualified experts to determine their fair market value.
A few words of caution about using guide books and information given on antiques appraisal television programs. With regard to guide books, if they are not of recent origin, they can provide inaccurate valuations which are usually to the owner's disadvantage. Television antique and collectible shows make for great TV but again are edited to present usually higher priced and unusual items. Also, these TV programs have the advantage of the owner physically presenting the item to be appraised.
Our policy on information requests concerning your string instruments: We do not accept e mail inquiries concerning the provision of information on your string instruments.. Requests made will no longer be answered. This information is best obtained by taking the instrument to a local competent violin shop.